A local guide to Lindenhurst, an incorporated village on Long Island's South Shore in the Town of Babylon, Suffolk County. Written by Jack Cutrone, MRP, PSA, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson with Patriot Real Properties, who works with buyers, sellers and investors throughout Suffolk and Nassau Counties.
Lindenhurst, NY Real Estate & Community Guide
Living in Lindenhurst, Long Island
Lindenhurst is an incorporated village in the Town of Babylon, Suffolk County, set along the Great South Bay on Long Island’s South Shore. Much of the village is made up of established residential streets, and its downtown is centered on Wellwood Avenue, where restaurants, local shops, Village Square and the Lindenhurst Long Island Rail Road station sit within a few blocks of one another.
The village also has parks, a marina and bayfront open space, a calendar of community events, and access to Montauk Highway, Sunrise Highway, Route 109 and the Southern State Parkway. This guide covers the housing market, downtown, recreation, transportation and history of Lindenhurst for anyone thinking about buying, selling or investing here.
Location: Incorporated Village of Lindenhurst, Town of Babylon, Suffolk County, Long Island, New York · ZIP code: 11757 (the ZIP code also covers areas outside the village, such as North Lindenhurst) · Neighboring communities: North Lindenhurst, Copiague, West Babylon and Babylon
Lindenhurst at a Glance
-
Population (2020 Census): 27,148
-
Population estimate (July 1, 2025): 27,258
-
Households: 8,452
-
Owner-occupied housing rate: 87.6%
-
Median household income: $130,128
-
Median value of owner-occupied homes: $521,500
-
Persons per household: 3.21
-
Residents age 65 and older: 14.4%
-
Veterans: 776
-
Mean travel time to work: 32.2 minutes
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, QuickFacts for Lindenhurst village, New York. Population figures are the April 1, 2020 Census count and the July 1, 2025 estimate; residents 65+ is a 2025 estimate; other figures are American Community Survey 5-year estimates for 2020–2024. Census home values are owner-reported and are not the same as current sale prices.
Lindenhurst Market Snapshot
-
Median sale price (all home types): $679,660
-
Year-over-year change: up 3.8%
-
Homes sold: 56 (down 1.2% year over year)
-
Median days on market: 22 days (7 fewer than a year earlier)
-
Sale-to-list ratio: about 103.6%
-
Homes sold above list price: about 74.7%
Source: Redfin, Lindenhurst, NY housing market data for the three months ending July 2026 (the most recent period available when this page was published in October 2026). Redfin’s Lindenhurst area is not identical to the Census village boundary or ZIP code 11757. Figures shift from period to period depending on which homes sell.
Lindenhurst Real Estate
Recent numbers point to a competitive market. In Redfin’s data for the three months ending July 2026, homes sold for about 103.6% of their list price, roughly three out of four homes sold above asking, and the median home spent about 22 days on the market. Those are area-wide figures, though. Results for an individual home depend on its location, condition, size, renovations, lot, distance to the water, flood-zone status, property taxes, open permits and the competition on the market at the same time.
Housing in Lindenhurst
Lindenhurst’s housing stock reflects more than a century of growth. Buyers will see Capes, ranches, Colonials, split-levels and high-ranch homes, older houses closer to the village center, and many homes that have been expanded or renovated over the years. Near the bay, some streets run along canals, and a portion of the homes there have water access. Waterfront and canal-area properties are only one part of the market, and characteristics vary considerably from street to street.
For homes near the water, buyers should independently investigate the flood-zone designation, flood insurance requirements, elevation information, the property’s condition, permits, the condition of any bulkhead, and applicable local regulations, using qualified professionals and official sources.
As a Pricing Strategy Advisor (PSA), I help buyers and sellers evaluate recent comparable sales, competing inventory, property characteristics and current market conditions when making pricing decisions in Lindenhurst and throughout Long Island.
Education
The Village of Lindenhurst is served by the Lindenhurst Union Free School District, which according to the Town of Babylon also serves North Lindenhurst. The district lists six elementary schools, Lindenhurst Middle School, The Lindenhurst Academy and Lindenhurst High School.
The 11757 ZIP code does not line up exactly with the district. The Town of Babylon notes, for example, that the American Venice section, which uses a Lindenhurst mailing address, is in the Copiague School District.
Lindenhurst Memorial Library
The Lindenhurst Memorial Library is located at 1 Lee Avenue, Lindenhurst, NY 11757, and offers programs and services for library-district residents. Check the library for current hours and programs.
School district and attendance boundaries can vary by property. Buyers should independently verify the school district for any specific address directly with the district.
Parks, Waterfront & Recreation
Lindenhurst Village Park – 336 North Alleghany Avenue
The village’s largest park has a playground, baseball and softball fields, a basketball court, tennis and pickleball courts, and open lawn, and it borders Fellers Pond. The village’s 9/11 Memorial Garden, with plaques, plantings and benches for quiet reflection, is on the south side of the park along Byrd Street.
Shore Road Park
Shore Road Park sits on the Great South Bay between Arctic Street and South Bay Street. The village renovated its playground in 2023, and the park has open grass and benches facing the bay.
Charles J. Cowan Marina
The Village marina is at the southern end of South Wellwood Avenue, with views across the Great South Bay, benches and areas for fishing and crabbing. The village notes that a permit is required for crabbing.
Venetian Shores Park
The Town of Babylon’s Venetian Shores Park, at 850 Venetian Boulevard, has a bay beach, spray park, playground and picnic area. Access is limited to Town of Babylon residents: a Town beach permit or digital pass is required, and walk-in visitors must show ID with a Town of Babylon address. Non-residents are not admitted.
Park amenities, hours, permits and access rules can change. Check with the Village of Lindenhurst or the Town of Babylon for current information before visiting.
Downtown Lindenhurst & Village Square
Downtown Lindenhurst runs along Wellwood Avenue on both sides of the railroad, with Hoffman Avenue connecting the main street to the LIRR station. Restaurants, cafes, bars, shops and service businesses fill much of this stretch, and the compact layout makes the downtown core easy to explore on foot. Downtown has also become a regular place to eat, see live entertainment and attend community events.
Lindenhurst Village Square
116 North Wellwood Avenue, Lindenhurst, NY 11757
Village Square is a public gathering space in the heart of downtown. The Village of Lindenhurst describes it as a central spot for community events and relaxation, with seating, picnic tables, landscaping and open space. It hosts events such as the summer concert series and is the endpoint of the holiday parade and tree lighting.
Event schedules and downtown businesses change. Check the Village of Lindenhurst and the Lindenhurst Chamber of Commerce for current information.
Things to Do in Lindenhurst
-
Walk Wellwood Avenue and Hoffman Avenue for dinner, drinks and local shopping.
-
Catch a free summer concert in Village Square.
-
Attend the Springfest Street Fair or Wednesdays on Wellwood, downtown street events organized with the Lindenhurst Chamber of Commerce.
-
See a play at the Manes Studio Theatre of Long Island at 141 South Wellwood Avenue.
-
Watch the sunset over the Great South Bay from Shore Road Park or the Charles J. Cowan Marina.
-
Use the courts, fields and playground at Lindenhurst Village Park.
-
Join seasonal village traditions such as Winter on Wellwood, the holiday parade and tree lighting.
Events, dates, hours and availability change. Check with each organization for current details.
Restaurants in Lindenhurst
A cross-section of local dining in Lindenhurst, listed in no particular order:
The Village Lanterne – A German restaurant at 155 North Wellwood Avenue serving traditional dishes, with desserts from its Black Forest Bakery.
Pino Wine Bar & Bistro – A downtown wine bar and bistro at 143 North Wellwood Avenue with an extensive wine list alongside pasta, steak and seafood.
Hermanas Kitchen and Cocktails – Latin-inspired cooking and craft cocktails at 136 South Wellwood Avenue.
The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst – Pizza and Italian fare at 177 South Wellwood Avenue, part of a small group of local pizzerias.
Restoration Kitchen & Cocktails – An American restaurant at 49 East Hoffman Avenue, near the train station, that donates its net profits to local charities.
Taheni – Fast-casual Mediterranean food at 296 East Montauk Highway.
Belfast Gastropub – An Irish gastropub at 101 North Wellwood Avenue in downtown Lindenhurst.
Restaurants, menus and operating hours can change. Check directly with the restaurant for current information.
Shopping & Local Businesses
Lindenhurst has three main commercial corridors. Wellwood Avenue is the village's main street, with independent shops, restaurants, salons and professional offices clustered downtown. Montauk Highway, which crosses the southern part of the village, carries a mix of restaurants, service businesses and everyday retail. Sunrise Highway, to the north, is lined with retail and service businesses that also serve surrounding communities.
Businesses along these corridors change over time. Check directly with individual businesses for current information.
Lindenhurst LIRR & Transportation
Lindenhurst has its own Long Island Rail Road station on the Babylon Branch, located downtown near Wellwood Avenue and Hoffman Avenue. The MTA lists the station as fully accessible, with an elevator. Babylon Branch trains connect Lindenhurst with western Long Island and New York City terminals; train times, transfers and terminals vary by schedule, so check the MTA for current timetables.
By car, Wellwood Avenue is the village’s main north–south road, connecting to Sunrise Highway (NY 27) and the Southern State Parkway. Montauk Highway runs east–west through the village, and Route 109 is close by to the east.
According to the U.S. Census Bureau (American Community Survey, 2020–2024), the mean travel time to work for Lindenhurst village residents is about 32.2 minutes. Check the MTA for current LIRR schedules, fares and parking.
A Little Lindenhurst History
Lindenhurst began as the City of Breslau, formally dedicated in 1870 by developers Thomas and Abby Welwood and Charles S. Schleier, a German immigrant from Breslau. The new community was marketed largely to German immigrants. In 1891 it was renamed Lindenhurst, a name inspired by the area's linden trees. According to the Town of Babylon, the change followed negative publicity tied to the founders' legal disputes and an unsolved 1887 murder, not anti-German sentiment during World War I as is sometimes said. Lindenhurst incorporated as a village in 1923.
Historical summary based on information from the Village of Lindenhurst and the Town of Babylon.
Jack’s Local Take
A local perspective from Jack Cutrone
“Lindenhurst is one of the South Shore communities I watch closely, because there is a lot going on here. You have established residential streets, an active downtown, the LIRR, restaurants and the Great South Bay all in one village.
The current numbers are a reason for buyers and sellers to pay attention. When most homes are selling above asking price, buyers need to understand the competition before they write an offer. Sellers, on the other hand, still need to price correctly instead of assuming every house will automatically go over list.
Homes in Lindenhurst can also differ a lot depending on location, condition, renovations, lot, taxes and how close they are to the water. That’s why I’d rather look at the specific property and the most recent comparable sales than rely on a broad online estimate.”
— Jack Cutrone, MRP, PSA, Licensed Real Estate Salesperson, Patriot Real Properties. This section reflects my professional perspective as a local real estate agent, not an objective or statistical claim.
Buying a Home in Lindenhurst
In a market where many homes sell above asking, preparation matters. Before making an offer in Lindenhurst, review recent comparable sales and understand how much competition a home is likely to draw. Then look at the full cost of ownership: property taxes, the age and condition of the roof, heating and cooling systems, utilities, any renovations you would want to make, and whether past improvements have the proper permits and certificates of occupancy (COs). A professional inspection, your financing and closing costs, and the home’s location within the village all belong in the decision. For homes near the water, include flood-zone status and flood insurance in your research.
First-time buyers can start with my First-Time Home Buyer Guide for Long Island, and you can learn more about how I work with buyers on my Buy a Home page.
As a Military Relocation Professional (MRP), I also work with veterans and military families considering homeownership on Long Island and can help navigate the real estate side of the process alongside their lender, attorney and other professionals.
I don't provide mortgage, legal, engineering, flood-insurance or tax advice. Consult a qualified lender, attorney, inspector, insurance agent or tax professional for those questions.
Selling a Home in Lindenhurst
A competitive market does not mean every home sells itself. Buyers in Lindenhurst compare homes carefully, and an overpriced listing can lose attention quickly even when inventory is tight. A sound pricing strategy draws on recent comparable sales, the homes you will compete against, your home’s condition and improvements, its location and lot, and, where it applies, its waterfront features and flood-zone status.
As a Pricing Strategy Advisor (PSA), I put that information together to recommend a list price and a marketing plan suited to your property. Visit my Sell a Home page to see how I approach listings.
Every home and market is different. No sale price, number of offers or timeline can be guaranteed.
Investing in Lindenhurst
Investors look at Lindenhurst for several reasons: its own LIRR station, an active downtown, an established residential housing stock, commercial corridors on Wellwood Avenue, Montauk Highway and Sunrise Highway, and waterfront areas along the Great South Bay. Some downtown properties combine commercial and residential uses.
Every investment property should be evaluated on its own. Investors should independently investigate zoning, permitted uses, Village and Town rental regulations, property taxes, insurance, flood considerations, rental income, operating expenses, financing and the property’s condition. I can help you review comparable sales and local market conditions for residential and investment properties in Lindenhurst and throughout Suffolk County.
Nothing on this page is legal, tax or financial advice. For zoning, legal, tax and financing questions, consult the appropriate licensed professionals.
Frequently Asked Questions About Lindenhurst, NY
What county is Lindenhurst in?
Lindenhurst is located in Suffolk County, New York.
What town is Lindenhurst in?
The incorporated Village of Lindenhurst is located within the Town of Babylon.
Is Lindenhurst on the North Shore or South Shore?
Lindenhurst is on Long Island’s South Shore, along the Great South Bay.
Does Lindenhurst have an LIRR station?
Yes. Lindenhurst has its own Long Island Rail Road station on the Babylon Branch, located downtown.
What is the population of Lindenhurst?
The 2020 Census counted 27,148 residents in the Village of Lindenhurst. The Census Bureau estimated the village population at 27,258 as of July 1, 2025.
What is the Lindenhurst real estate market like?
According to Redfin, for the three months ending July 2026 the median sale price in Lindenhurst was about $679,660, up 3.8% from a year earlier. Homes spent a median of 22 days on the market and sold for about 103.6% of list price, and roughly 74.7% sold above list.
What types of homes are found in Lindenhurst?
Lindenhurst includes Capes, ranches, Colonials, split-levels, expanded and renovated homes, older homes near the village center, and some canal-area and waterfront properties.
Is there a downtown in Lindenhurst?
Yes. Downtown Lindenhurst is centered on Wellwood Avenue and Hoffman Avenue, with restaurants, shops, Village Square and the LIRR station.
Is Lindenhurst near the water?
Yes. Lindenhurst borders the Great South Bay and has bayfront parks and a marina. Not every property is on the water or in a flood zone, so buyers should check each property individually.
What should buyers consider before buying in Lindenhurst?
Buyers should consider price and recent comparable sales, property taxes, condition, location, permits and COs, transportation, and flood-zone status for properties near the water.
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts (Lindenhurst village, NY); Redfin Lindenhurst housing market data; Village of Lindenhurst; Town of Babylon; Lindenhurst Union Free School District; MTA Long Island Rail Road; Lindenhurst Chamber of Commerce; official restaurant websites.
Thinking About Buying, Selling or Investing in Lindenhurst?
I work with buyers, sellers, investors, first-time homebuyers, veterans and military families throughout Lindenhurst, Suffolk County, Nassau County and Long Island.
Whether you are thinking about buying your first home, selling a property near the bay or evaluating an investment, I can help you understand what the current Lindenhurst market means for you.
Jack Cutrone, MRP, PSA
Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
Patriot Real Properties
791 Middle Country Rd, Selden, NY 11784
(631) 926-9592
Jack@PatriotRealProperties.com
JackCutrone.com